| Platinum | Barro's Pizza |
| Gold | Oregano's |
| Silver | Taste of Italy Pizza Inc |
| Bronze | Garden Pizza Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | 1 Brother's Pizza Inc |
| Top Pick | AZ Pizza Company |
| Top Pick | Babbo Italian Eatery |
| Top Pick | Mod Pizza |
| Top Pick | Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom |
| Top Pick | Peter Piper Pizza |